One day into his new job as charity enforcer and Lord Michael Grade – the man once responsible for scrapping Dr Who from the BBC – has been warned that the fundraising reforms he has also backed are set to cost the industry over £2bn in lost income by 2020.
Research by the think tank Rogare, part of the Centre for Sustainable Philanthropy at Plymouth University, says that fundraisers expected a mean fall of 14% in fundraised income in their financial years beginning in 2016, and a fall of 17% by 2020.
Based on a survey of more than 500 fundraisers, the report estimates that the changes could reduce fundraising income by about 20% within five years, equivalent to £2bn, based on current donation levels.
The report, from an analysis carried out by Professor Adrian Sargeant, states: “Longer-term projections are even more troubling as the effect of the changes will compound over time as fewer donors are recruited, the quality of service they receive falls and levels of attrition begin to rise.”
The survey also reveals that more than three-quarters of respondents (77%) were opposed to the launch of the Fundraising Preference Service; of those 44% said the Institute of Fundraising should be mandated to oppose it, while 8% said the sector should refuse to co-operate with the FPS entirely. Sargeant said: “It’s clear there is some disquiet in the fundraising community about FPS and what the profession’s response to it should be.”
Even more (82%) believe that adopting an opt-in system for fundraising would have a “significant” or “very significant” negative impact on their marketing activities.
There was a greater split of opinion when it comes to the need for a new regulator, with 46% for and 42% against.
The findings will make for an interesting charity summit, convened at short notice by the author of the reforms, NCVO chief Sir Stuart Etherington.
Sargent added: “Fundraisers now have access to our findings and it will be up to them, having told us what they feel and think, whether they choose to act on some of those thoughts and feelings.”
Grade becomes charity enforcer but critics fume
Etherington calls urgent summit of top UK charities
Charities face legal threat over new marketing rules
Opt-in switch to rip £36m hole in RNLI’s finances
Graham slams ‘confusing’ charity preference service
Charity rules ludicrous, say agencies
IoF data advice two years out of date
Charities face marketing activity ban
Charity rethink branded incompetent
Charity chiefs lay blame on agencies
FRSB axed in charity marketing purge
ICO warns of charity witch-hunt
Charities flayed in new data row
Charities rocked by ICO call demands
600 jobs go as charity backlash bites
Charities cleared over Olive’s suicide
Colin Lloyd: fundraising out of control
Save the Children to axe cold calling
Industry staggered by BBC ignorance
Minister demands charity action
Charities using illegal marketing data
Charities hit again as row escalates
Charities in dock over donor blitz