Donors find most DM ‘very annoying’

Donors find most DM ‘very annoying’Charities are being urged to rethink their marketing strategies after a damning report claimed most people find many DM techniques – including email, text message, and telemarketing activity – “very annoying”.
The research, published by consultancy nfpSynergy, will make worrying reading for many in sector as direct marketing is such a key discipline within most organisations. They spend over £300m a year – and rising – on direct mail alone, making it the third highest spending sector in the UK.
The study revealed that people are much more likely to donate to charities after viewing an ad campaign – either on TV or online – than through most DM techniques.
Doorstep fundraising is seen as the biggest villain, with 54% of people finding it very annoying, while 51% feel the same about being asked to donate on the telephone. A third (36%) get very annoyed when they are approached by a fundraiser on the street.
More modern methods are also unpopular, with 33% irritated by text messages and 20% unhappy with receiving emails.
The new data, based on a survey of 1,000 British adults, did show that some fundraising methods sit well with the public. Over a third were happy to be asked to donate via collection tins and online ads, while around a quarter find face-to-face, radio and TV approaches acceptable.
Despite the high levels of annoyance, people said they did understand that some methods are effective ways to raise money. These included newspaper/magazine ads (42%), radio (40%), collection tins (35%) and direct mail appeals (31%).
When asked for their preferred way to be asked for money, just 2% would choose being asked on their doorstep and 1% on the telephone.
nfpSynergy chief Joe Saxton said: “The Holy Grail in fundraising must be to maximise the money raised and minimise the aggravation it causes. This data gives a good indication that we are not winning this battle.
“We as a fundraising sector have to start working out ways of reducing the annoyance from some of our most effective and successful methods. Charities must ensure people can opt out of telephone calls and being badgered on their doorstep and they have to look at their direct marketing. It’s no good thinking that people are happy with certain methods and leaving it at that if those are not the ones that can raise the big bucks.”

Related stories
Fundraising complaints rise 10%
Charities dismiss marketing moans
Threatening CRUK mailer banned
Marie Curie agency ‘misled public’
Lloyd wins day as charity enforcer
Call for charity complaint overhaul