Brand owners are facing a serious imbalance in how they approach digital optimisation, with most of their effort concentrated around sealing the transaction rather than what happens afterwards, including whether people return, engage with the product or make use of new features.
That is according to the new State of Experimentation 2026 report from agentic experience optimisation platform Wingify, which reveals that nearly half (45%) of feature experiments which test how digital products work focus on conversion rate optimisation (CRO), while just 6% target retention and engagement.
The emphasis on conversion is particularly pronounced in retail, where CRO-focused experiments account for 52% of feature testing in home and garden, 48% in apparel and fashion and 44% in food and grocery. But this focus on the transaction often comes at the expense of other forms of optimisation: just 5% of all feature experiments focus on whether customers discover and use new features.
The report recommends combining client-side web experimentation, which helps businesses refine the elements of their websites and digital experiences, with server-side feature experimentation, which tests the underlying logic and functionality. Together, the approaches allow brands to validate everything from a new CTA to a new pricing model before changes reach customers.
The State of Experimentation 2026 benchmarks organisational maturity, analyses where feature testing is concentrated across sectors including retail, travel, finance and media, and explores how web and feature experimentation can be combined to improve experiences across the customer journey.
Its survey of 108 organisations across 21 industries found that nine in ten respondents considered their experimentation programmes to be either “strategic” or “transformative”. More than a third (36%) classified their programmes as transformative, meaning experimentation is considered a core organisational competency, while 54% placed themselves in the strategic category, where testing is supported by leadership and guided by data.
The survey also points to constraints on the scale of experimentation. More than half of organisations (56%) run just one or two tests a month, while 55% cite limited team capacity as a barrier to increasing activity.
Wingify vice-president of marketing John Hughes said: “If there is one huge, overlooked opportunity here, it is the underinvestment in creating long-lasting customer relationships. In a digital economy where customer acquisition costs are continuously climbing, ignoring the ‘leaky bucket’ of user churn is a dangerous strategic blind spot.
“The most successful brands in 2026 are shifting their focus from ‘how do we get them in the door?’ to ‘how do we keep them here?’ That requires a radical prioritisation of logged-in experiences, personalised engagement features and post-purchase onboarding journeys.”
The full report can be downloaded from the Wingify website>
Related stories
Loyalty schemes failing to make us feel special, say Brits
Brands urged to act to ensure loyal shoppers feel valued
Brands up loyalty spend as ROI, data and retention soar
Brands crave personalisation but marketers are too busy


Be the first to comment on "Brands fail to plug digital optimisation ‘leaky bucket’"