How can brands soften the blow of mail price hikes?

Royal Mail may have been forced to scrap its controversial price rises for wholesale customers – which would have seen the cost of some letters soar by up to 36% – but the new set of lower increases is still due to come into force on December 7.

The move comes despite the ongoing row over service levels, which, according to some reports, has seen even “Czech sphinx” billionaire owner Daniel Kretinsky directly intervene in crisis talks with the Government.

But as brands brace themselves for yet another round of price rises of between 12% and 21%, depending on the mail category, what can they do to keep the print presses rolling with highly effective direct mail effective? Decision Marketing asks industry experts for their take.

First up is Join the Dots managing director Ben Briggs, who reckons that most brands, and their agencies, should already be looking at better data sources and selections and proper suppression, but the bigger savings and opportunities come earlier, while the pack and the plan are still being decided.

Briggs explains: “Start with the format, if a pack is a few grams into the next weight step, or a touch bigger than letter size, you pay for it on every item, bring the printer and mailing house in at the brief and those problems get fixed while they’re cheap to change.

“I wouldn’t cut volume evenly either, modelling will show which segments stopped paying back at the new price, so drop those. Frequency is worth testing too, because plenty of programmes still mail on a cadence someone set years ago.”

Briggs argues that while fewer, better mailings might do more, brands will only find out by measuring retention and value over a proper period, where it can be evaluated properly, response curves are longer than the other channels in the mix, but mail stands out from the compound value it creates overtime.

He also reckons that partially addressed mail and door drops could pick up some cold acquisition, with digital doing more of the early work in driving awareness and intrigue, if the channels are planned together against the same objective. I’d be wary of cheapening packs across the board.

Briggs cites research from Jicmail and Join the Dots’ own client data that shows people keep mail , engage with it and go back to it, over and over again, so a stronger pack that recruits more loyal customers can still earn its place after a price rise.

He adds: “What would make the most difference is the supply chain working much more closely together. Data, planners, creatives, printers, mailing houses, and access providers all affect what a pack ends up costing, yet they tend to work one after another without seeing each other’s constraints. Postage costs are shaped by all those decisions, so it needs all those people round the table.”

Over at PDV managing director Nigel Goldthorpe maintains that the rising costs mean every piece of direct mail needs to earn its place and for him that starts with getting the data right at the point of collection, so fewer packs go to inaccurate or outdated addresses.

He continues: “Audience insight helps you decide who’s worth mailing in the first place. Looking at who’s responded, bought or donated before can help you spot which prospects are most likely to engage and what message or offer might work for them.

“That means you can trim the mailing where it makes sense and protect the volume where you’re most likely to see a return.”

Eight Group chief executive Lance Hill is also a huge “clean data” advocate, insisting that now more than ever is the time to ensure the quality of customer and acquisition data is accurate.

Hill continues: “Data cleansing and suppression tools have been around for years, but the analysis and quality of these tools is far better so it really is an opportunity to reduce mailing waste and only mail people or businesses that are actually in existence or have a high propensity to respond.

“Once data is sorted it then comes down to ensuring the correct postage product is used and this is where working closely with a credible mail producer comes into play. We want to help our clients get the maximum ROI out of their campaigns, so it is 100% in our interest to advise our clients accordingly.

“Start throwing in Jicmail data analysis as well and the case for staying in the channel of mail becomes stronger, it’s all about using the knowledge and support available.”

It is a theme that fuelled the launch of The Software Bureau nearly three decades ago, founded on a simple observation that quality data is at the heart of every campaign.

Managing director Martin Rides has 35 years’ experience in the world of data and direct mail and has worked across many areas of the industry including agencies, mail production and data bureaux. After 9 years running a specialist direct mail consulting practice, he returned to The Software Bureau as MD in 2015.

Rides says: “Every increase in Royal Mail postage prices reinforces a simple truth: poor data is becoming increasingly expensive. A duplicate record, gone-away address, deceased individual or outdated contact is no longer just a data quality problem, it is money wasted on every campaign.

“At The Software Bureau, we’ve long advocated a Lean DM approach. By cleansing data, removing duplicates, suppressing deceased records, identifying gone-aways and updating customers with their latest known address where appropriate, organisations can eliminate waste before a single item enters production and improve the accuracy of every campaign.

“The most effective response to rising postage costs isn’t always to mail more selectively, it’s to mail more intelligently. However, to make this practical at scale, organisations and mailing providers need access to the right data quality software, capable of cleansing, validating and enhancing mailing data quickly within production timescales.

“With the right tools in place, marketers can focus their budget on the people most likely to respond, often achieving better results while sending fewer mail pieces. In many cases, mailing less delivers more.”

Even so, former Go Inspire CEO and “lifer” Patrick Headley, who is now a performance coach, board advisor, and company founder, believes that while the obvious starting point is better data management, brands should look beyond simply reducing mailing volumes.

He explains: “My concern is that we spend too much time talking about the cost of direct mail and not enough time talking about its value but there are several things I would encourage brands to consider.

“Firstly, measure the right things. The cost per item is largely irrelevant if the campaign delivers a strong return. Brands should be looking at cost per acquisition, customer lifetime value and overall campaign profitability. A more expensive mailing that generates better engagement and conversion can be considerably more profitable than a cheaper alternative.

“Secondly, look at the entire mailing, not just the postage. Format, weight, paper specification and production methods can all influence the overall cost. Working collaboratively with print and mailing partners at the planning stage can often identify efficiencies without compromising the effectiveness of the communication.

“Thirdly, make direct mail part of a wider marketing strategy. Combining physical mail with digital activity, email and other channels can improve response and make the overall investment work harder. The objective should be to maximise the return from every customer interaction.

“Fourthly, don’t forget existing customers. With customer acquisition costs continuing to challenge brands, retention, reactivation and cross-selling deserve just as much attention as prospecting. Direct mail can be particularly effective when used intelligently with customers who already know the brand.

“Finally, I would caution against simply cutting volumes in response to higher prices. There is a danger that we end up managing costs rather than growing businesses. If reducing mailing volumes means sacrificing profitable customers, we haven’t really achieved anything.”

Headley concludes: “My advice would be simple: don’t send less mail just because it costs more. Send smarter mail, measure it properly and make sure every piece has a commercial purpose.

“Royal Mail’s increases are undoubtedly frustrating, but they should also encourage the industry to demonstrate the real commercial value of physical communication.”

Related stories
Govt calls top-level summit over Royal Mail’s future
Royal Mail halts DM26 rollout but Xmas ‘still in doubt’
New postal bust-up sparks fears of Christmas chaos
Royal Mail slashes disputed price rises in major U-turn
Ofcom slams brakes on Royal Mail price rises…for now
A nasty case of déjà vu as Royal Mail hikes prices again
Posties agree landmark deal for roll out of USO changes

Be the first to comment on "How can brands soften the blow of mail price hikes?"

Leave a comment